Hi James,
Archive pages do not provide much benefit at all in search engines:
1. If they are a single author website, they will be the same content as your homepage/author page/archive page/category pages.
2. As they are archives of existing content, none of the content is unique
I personally have them disabled, and it is common that other sites do as well, especially ones based on Wordpress
I find it is better to have a date based archive which you can then have indexed, as this provides a unique outlook. Mashable does this:
http://mashable.com/2013/12/
and so do we:
http://searchbuzz.co/archive/
This is of course just a personal approach and avoids the duplicate title issue.
If you want to keep the archive pages for usability, but stop them appearing in search results, simply noindex those pages, Yoast can do that for you - you can also use Yoast to rename the page title to something different so the title is never a duplicate, so it physically adds "Page 2 of 50" or something in the title tag of the page.
Ash