Jon,
Honestly, at this point, I'm just glad someone from Moz has acknowledged this issue as an issue. That said, I would like to discuss things further with you though I don't use Skype. Phone works best for me. Couple additional notes based on your response.
Random Page Grades
I realize this may be how you intended, but this is the wrong place for this. I need, and I'm sure I'm not alone in this, a page grade tools that reports on the pages and keyword combos I want and only what I want. Again, it wouldn't be that bad if this could be overridden, but it can't. They just show up the next week making this a pointless tool... that is unless you're only concerned with "interesting data". Not only is it overwhelming to see multiple keywords per page yet only one of them gets a good grade, it's fundamentally just wrong. Every other page grade tools either grade a single page for one keyword, or grades a single page for a set of keywords. Your tool grade the same page over and over again for every keyword it see ranked in a search engine, which for most of my sites, is a lot! All this does is show me that "I'm failing at on page" to my clients if I were to show this to them. This forces me to created my own reports (which take entirely too much time) to prove to them I am doing what I promised.
Delete and ‘Add and Manage’
Yes, your tools does need a lot of work. The part that really annoys me is that I left Moz months ago and expressed my concerns with this tool to Aaron (don't remember last name). He contacted me a few months after that telling me that this tool had some major done on it. then I sign back up and realize that is does basically the same thing. Very disappointing indeed.
Timeline for turn fixing
I also understand that your company should only focus on a few things at once. I get this. However, it just really bothers me that this tool doesn't do and can't really accomplish what it advertises that it does. One could argue that it does, but as soon as I showed this counter argument, I'm sure most would side with me on this one.
This hasn't been the only issue of false advertisement I've seen with you guys either. There have been a number of things that I've brought up, most of which were just removed from your front end web copy after I mentioned them. I just want the tools to do what it's supposed to do.
As to the overhaul, you're right, it needs one. When doing it, keep in mind that WE should have control over what is scanned and the keyword associations for those pages. Just like a "remembered" version of the manual one. That's all it needs to do. Honestly, you could make it even cooler by adding a checkbox on the manual one to "add to on page grader". Additionally, you could consider leaving the auto scanning that it does now. However, there needs to be a way to defeat it. This has to happen!! I simple "on/off" would be just fine. Or, you could do the add/manage page grades in which one could delete a page grade, but unlike what it does now, it needs to stay removed! If I wanted to see it regraded for the same keyword/landing page combo, I'd just wait until next week when the next scan was complete. Basically, the current delete button here is one of the most pointless things I've ever seen.
Anyways, again, I do appreciate your time and concern here, but I would like to chat more. Can you email me to my registered email, then I can provide a phone to call me?
Thanks,
Micha