Edward
Your current title chases a more niche market - "online psychic readings" as compared to "psychic readings". So any change to the title - ie deleting online - at the start could impact how you rank now for online psychic readings. It is actually a treacherous game playing with titles - especially if you rank well in key areas.
ie Big companies would do it, only whilst simultaneously running a massive above the line advertising campaign etc. Every click counts, cant afford to lose one.
Am trying to make the point a change to title is not to be done lightly. I built a tool so I can review titles, independently here is the link https://www.predikkta.com/products/free-serp-optimizer-tool.html - you can measure pixels and also see what your Ad looks like next to competitors.
All that said on your examples if you have created some strong backlinks I would jump to the latter one. But I am v concerned about your domain authority. Accordingly I would target niche until you have built up your DA a little more. I am conservative though. ie the below title is 500 pixels. Then perhaps your H1 "psychic readings".
Online Psychic Readings | Tarot, Astrology & Chat | Zenory
Moving forward this way you keep your primary keyword insitu whilst keeping working on DA for the key pages.
It is a very difficult and nebulous business advising on titles. So you know your site best and what risks you are prepared to take. The key focus for me looking at your site is DA, everything else looks reasonable...
Ask away though. Hope this is not too muddy.