I agree with with the sentiment of this post and respect to SEO moz for keeping it live and respect to Big J for having the courage to post a counter argument.
I do beleive that Google's ultimate goal with be to "take out" manual intevention ie SEO consultants have their days numbered...
There is a kind of new age fundamantalist vibe about about some SEO consultants, an arrogant beleif that they can out wit the Google gods. But occassionally out of all the guff an occasional puff of wisdom wafts out of all the hyperbole...
In truth I'm 50% on the SEO train, the other half is cynical...


