How do you decide which answers to trust on here?

[qlkasdjfw]

There are certain influential people on this forum (i'm not naming names) that give answers that don't answer much and are much more a response to a question rather than an actual answer.

[EGOL]

Sometimes "perspectives" are more valuable than "answers".

Since most of the people who post in public Q&A are donating their time to your question maybe it is best to view their response as a  gift that can be ignored or accepted.

[qlkasdjfw]

I agree EGOL, it's very charitable for some of the forum members to give feedback in any capacity.

[waynekolenchuk]

It's a valid question. I've been a web developer since 1996 with an interest in search long before the term SEO was coined but am not very active on SEO Moz so my profile doesn't present me as being very knowledgeable.

Bear in mind that, as in life, people are participating in this forum for all kinds of reasons.

SEO Moz is a great resource, and as you take advantage of it you will start to form your own opinions. Ask questions when you are stumped, and look for a consensus among helpful answers. That's what I do.

[MBayes]

I think the concept of an influential person is an individual assumption. That's really the core of the question.  I know I spend 30 minutes a day or so on the Q.A. and do try and give valuable answers.  It's not charity, it's a business culture.

I feel that in In SEO there are many who feel they want to help, but don't want to give away there hard earned intellectual property or experience, which makes sense, so they have a tendency to teach people to fish, instead of handing them a fish (so to speak).

[SteveOllington]

Well I'm pretty sure, in fact I know, that I've answered questions before with an answer I thought was correct and then found out through others on here that it was in fact incorrect. I'd like to think that happens every time I'm wrong but possibly not (partially so the person who asked the question gets the right answer, but mainly because I like to know if I'm wrong about something).

So yeah, certainly I've given wrong answers accidentally but then there are people on here who are far more experienced than I am who I'm sure wouldn't make that same mistake. From spending time on here you get to know who the people are who really know their stuff and so I would trust their answers a lot. Also, I think most of us will be able to intuitively tell if something "seems wrong" and would question it.

[SteveOllington]

Haha yes EGOL and Alan, along with a couple of others on here...  I would certainly trust their answers above any paid experts too. They should form some kind of SEO A-Team!

[MBayes]

I think most of us have given the wrong answer at one time or another. Sometimes it's in the understanding of the question.  Thanks for your response!

[Netboost]

SEO is such a grey field that sometimes the amateur may be right and the 'guru' wrong. Even the troll may accidentally get it right.

Your experience is what will tell you something is wrong - listen to all the responses and then judge for yourself. And remember that the best way top learn is by making mistakes. If you are unsure run a test and see - just be sure to let the rest of us know how it goes - it may even earn you a couple of links.

If you see blatantly wrong or bad advice then why not comment and let the people know its wrong so others dont suffer

[BlueprintMarketing]

I did not know we had one free private question every month.

Thank you,

Thomas