Welcome to the Q&A Forum

You should also inform Google of your change of address via Google Webmaster Tools.

Thank you, Phil!  Makes sense now!

Totally helpful, thank you!

It appears that you have some technical issues with your website. I could be wrong but i suspect your CMS or whatever system youre using generates two different urls for the same page there are no canonicals set up. Before you dive in and set up 301s, i suggest you or your developers delve into your url creation and establish why you have two different urls for them same page. If its a system issue then get them to set up a canonical of one url to the other. Dr. Pete's post on duplicate content will provide more insight to that. I also spotted a few other techincal issues. You need to look at your 404 page as well. see examples below http://www.ferringway.com/local-venues/index.php http://www.ferringway.com/durango-activitiesss.php All the best.