These are just opinions.....
I see some people who offer SEO services for hire asking questions that share the websites of their clients. I don't think that they should post those in public.
I see some people who offer SEO services for hire asking some really noob questions. It's good that they are looking for eduction but probably best to take those private or hire a consultant.
Not a good idea to post the URL of your money site here or affiliate sites in low barrier to entry niches.
Sometimes I post a private question because I am looking for one reply that I think I would trust rather than opening a discussion and getting replies from people I don't know. I envision that difficult questions going to the "back room" are routed to appropriate people to answer rather than anybody opening them and "shooting from the hip" with an answer. I get replies from people like Dr Pete which is nice.
