Welcome to the Q&A Forum

Thanks Kevin! I was unaware of that email so I'll use that going forward. Thanks, Chris

Thanks Jordan! Appreciate it!

To answer my own question, from some Google searches and research, SNI is not supported by Moz currently.  They are working to add it, but it's not currently supported.  Hopefully that helps some other people. Thanks, Chris

The best advice I can give you is to check the 301 redirects. Also keep in mind that location and personalization could change the results. Try it on a few different incognito windows in Cincinnati just to be sure that it's actually lower. I know this is late, but it's also possible that Panda is moving this page lower because it looks a little templated to me. The top image looks a little bit like a stock image, for example, and I can't see a next step in the content section. If I were you, I'd insert more examples of your residential work in the page (this goes for commercial, etc. too) and try to get a call to action in the content. A large form might not be ideal, but maybe a button above the fold telling the user what to do next.