The Moz Q&A Forum

    • Forum
    • Questions
    • My Q&A
    • Users
    • Ask the Community

    Welcome to the Q&A Forum

    Browse the forum for helpful insights and fresh discussions about all things SEO.

    1. SEO and Digital Marketing Q&A Forum
    2. Categories
    3. Technical SEO Issues
    4. Duplicate exact match domains flagged by google - need help reinclusion

    Duplicate exact match domains flagged by google - need help reinclusion

    Technical SEO Issues
    37 28 9.3k
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as question
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • NickEubanks
      NickEubanks last edited by

      IMHO this is absolutely a content issue - opposed to spinning the content my suggestion would be to spent a little bit of $$ on having unique articles written targeting your top-level head and body keywords on each domain. You can get unique articles created for as little as $3 each using Odesk, Guru, or similar services - at this point I think spinning the content is not a great approach as Google has already recorded that these sites contain duplicate content and have been flagged as such, spent the money on some real content, re-work your post and page titles to reflect the new unique content, re-generate your sitemaps to include the new unique titles, and then re-submit

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • caneja
        caneja last edited by

        Are all of the domains being hosted under the same IP or have the same WHOIS info?  If so then I suggest you use different hosting providers (hence difference IP's) and change up the whois info for each of the domains (you can even use private).

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • KeriMorgret
          KeriMorgret last edited by

          Hi Ilya,

          It's been a few months since your original question. Are you still looking for some advice regarding this? Or do you have something you could share with us about what you did and let us know what we should do or not do if we're in a similar situation?

          Thanks!

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • DanLaBate
            DanLaBate last edited by

            Google beat up real estate sites for the same reason.  City + homes for sale type sites where all that changed was the city, especially where the sites would create mini fact pages for each city to try and pull rank for that area keyword search.

            Too many sites have used this technique and the market is saturated with such low quality sites.  Niche directories focusing on one city are better, but you need to watch the boiler plate content and also the listings you have need to contribute more to the conversation that just name, address telephone like the yellow pages.

            I doubt that Google is penalizing you for using the sale template, as mentioned so many sites use WordPress themes where the code structure is identical, and they are doing fine. I am curious if you are interlinking the websites.

            Good content, usefulness and fresh contributions to the site will always be a good recipe.  Fix and request re-inclusion and your shouldn't have a problem.

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
            • Thos003
              Thos003 last edited by

              Guilty!... and it takes one to know one. 😃

              You may have little chance of redeeming those sites. 301 redirects seem to wipe the crap clean. So you get the traffic and some of the link juice.

              Or...

              Pass the website on. Give it to someone else... Change the registration.

              ..... As an added note, I once heard Matt Cutts say, "Why would you want to buy one of these (burned) sites? Why wouldn't you start over with a new site? Then at least you are at ground zero instead of in a hole."

              ilyaelbert 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
              • nyanainc
                nyanainc @ilyaelbert last edited by

                Friend, dont spin or what ever, Create unique and useful content. Pandas crunch you...

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                • nyanainc
                  nyanainc last edited by

                  One question, are you using seo hosting also or they are all hosted in the same IP also?

                  ilyaelbert 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • JohannNortje
                    JohannNortje @rishil last edited by

                    I would also start by identifying the sites that brought the most traffic or money, I presume you running Adsense on these sites (side note also remember to have less ads above the fold since last layout update from Google).

                    The sites that are performing the best would be the ones I start with first when it comes to redesigning and making sure there is no further inter linking to the other sites.

                    Also make sure they are different CLASS C IP's.

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote -1
                    • elagaan
                      elagaan @DGSEO last edited by

                      Yeah I would like to see any pointers towards #2, my competition is using these black hat techniques and we would like to see the best way to compete with them!

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • BryanCasson
                        BryanCasson last edited by

                        Not the best idea, Google will hunt you down and shut you down, my guess is that they may even track you over multiple Google accounts and closely watch any related material. This is black hat all the way, I spend my life reporting pages like yours and get them shut down as quick as possible, they are viruses and have no reason to be in the results as they offer absolutely nothing to user experience. The only thing they give value to is your own pocket. There are Google Quality experts that are likely watching your sites like a hawk, my guess is that your re-inclusion requests will never be granted. I don't mean to be so blunt.. actually I do. What value are your bringing to the users?

                        ilyaelbert 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • ilyaelbert
                          ilyaelbert @VisualSense last edited by

                          No, they were red flagged on Webmaster Tools. It says your site has violated google guidelines.

                          I'm guessing that means its a manual penalty?

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                          • ilyaelbert
                            ilyaelbert @nyanainc last edited by

                            They're split up over 5-6 hosts...but identical WHOIS info......so there's maybe 20-30 per hosting account.

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • ilyaelbert
                              ilyaelbert @BryanCasson last edited by

                              What value? Same as ServiceMagic for instance...........We have as much right to be in a city as a local 'plumber'. What does a user in Montana care if the website looks the same as the one in New York?

                              BryanCasson 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote -1
                              • ilyaelbert
                                ilyaelbert @Thos003 last edited by

                                Link profile and exact match. I was able to grab the equivalent of plumberlosangeles in every major city in the country. They were #1 for new york, la, houston, philly, etc.....This was a 7 figure gross generating adventure.

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • BryanCasson
                                  BryanCasson @ilyaelbert last edited by

                                  If you want to target multiple locations then do it properly, do not duplicate your site over ever state, rather create a unique website with its own content that is more relevant to the location you are targeting. If they are unique enough then Google may consider them as you have put the time and effort into making them different. This also includes local phone numbers in each state to show that you are actually in the state.

                                  As for "What does a user in Montana care if the website looks the same as the one in New York?" - The problem is that local search may not dominate the right way in every state so the poor user in California see's 7 sites that all lead to the same place. This now becomes spam that annoys the hell out of the user. It is all about quality, 50+ pages all leading to the same place will result in a low quality experience to the users therefor will likely be denied.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • Court_H
                                    Court_H last edited by

                                    I have to agree with some of the other responses. Google is really cracking down on duplicate content and code.  It is time consuming to to write new content and redesign the sites, but you have to weigh the costs.  If the site is your livelihood then is worth working on it to get back in Google's good books.  If it is a site that you have created to get link juice then maybe you shouldn't put the time and effort into it.

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • Khem_Raj7
                                      Khem_Raj7 @DGSEO last edited by

                                      yes, I also want to see

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • Ascedia
                                        Ascedia last edited by

                                        Still mixing a lot of fact and fiction. Exact match domains still work. People have been saying that Google is 'going after' them, but that's not really true. There are plenty of exact match domains out there that are legitimate and separating the good guys from the bad guys is not going to happen at the domain level, doesn't make sense. Also, please keep in mind what the duplicate penalty content is for and how it's used. Having you site drop after an algo shift is not uncommon. I know plenty of domain farmers (in the 2 million+ domain range) and the biggest issues they face is bad rankings because of lack of content, overly aggressive link building, link wheels, etc).

                                        I believe that a warning in GWT means it's been flagged for a manual review, but might be totally wrong about that. In the 15 years that I have been doing this, I have never been warned or received an email about unnatural link building.

                                        I am currently chasing a link spammer/domain squatter right now so I can attest that those methods still work just fine if you know what you're doing. Once your site makes it in front of a human, its simple to figure out what other sites you have and what you are up to. Setting up single sites with different WHOIS info, different CBlocks, unique links, unique content, is extremely time consuming.

                                        I have found that I make  a lot more money focusing on a handful of sites and making them as best as possible, than I do managing 100s of sites with spun content, crappy links etc.

                                        Start thinking out side the box to get real visitors coming to the site and interacting, social signals are a huge part of search. Look at microformats and push reviews, give people a reason to interact and refer other people. City directories and sites like that still have a place in the search engines.

                                        If these sites really make money, I would go after local search because of the city name. I guess it depends on what you think a lot of money is. If all else fails, find a local biz that sells or caters to your KW and try to sell them the domain, especially if its already getting traffic.

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • MortenBratli
                                          MortenBratli @ilyaelbert last edited by

                                          If you made a good return on these sites, dont spin/spun or do anything like that.

                                          1. Replace all the content of the sites with good, high quality content. This will make them stick for ever.
                                          2. Keep the design, if its perfect in terms of seo. (i dont think it effect the ranking to have the same design on all sites..)
                                          3. You can link related cities to each other, after you have done 1 and 2 on the sites.

                                          Stop doing black hat and keep it real. All blackhat will come back and bit you in the a**.

                                          Good luck

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • inhouseseo
                                            inhouseseo last edited by

                                            Why don't you just come up with another scheme to make money!

                                            This one seems to have run its course. Be happy with the money you made and move on.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote -1
                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 2 / 2
                                            • First post
                                              Last post
                                            • New SEO manager needs help! Currently only about 15% of our live sitemap (~4 million url e-commerce site) is actually indexed in Google. What are best practices sitemaps for big sites with a lot of changing content?
                                              Nigel_Carr
                                              Nigel_Carr
                                              1
                                              4
                                              106

                                            • Exact Match Domain & Title Tag / URL
                                              Kusanagi17
                                              Kusanagi17
                                              0
                                              3
                                              552

                                            • How do i best utilize my exact keyword match domain names as landing pages?
                                              kadesmith
                                              kadesmith
                                              0
                                              2
                                              310

                                            • How to Recover from the Exact Match Domain Update last weekend?
                                              makedorid1971
                                              makedorid1971
                                              0
                                              3
                                              876

                                            • We have set up 301 redirects for pages from an old domain, but they aren't working and we are having duplicate content problems - Can you help?
                                              cprasad
                                              cprasad
                                              0
                                              12
                                              2.6k

                                            • Duplicate index.php/webpage pages on website. Help needed!
                                              MatthewBarby
                                              MatthewBarby
                                              0
                                              4
                                              691

                                            • Exact match domain
                                              EGOL
                                              EGOL
                                              0
                                              8
                                              2.6k

                                            • 301 Redirect with an Exact Domain name Match
                                              YannickVeys
                                              YannickVeys
                                              0
                                              7
                                              874

                                            Get started with Moz Pro!

                                            Unlock the power of advanced SEO tools and data-driven insights.

                                            Start my free trial
                                            Products
                                            • Moz Pro
                                            • Moz Local
                                            • Moz API
                                            • Moz Data
                                            • STAT
                                            • Product Updates
                                            Moz Solutions
                                            • SMB Solutions
                                            • Agency Solutions
                                            • Enterprise Solutions
                                            • Digital Marketers
                                            Free SEO Tools
                                            • Domain Authority Checker
                                            • Link Explorer
                                            • Keyword Explorer
                                            • Competitive Research
                                            • Brand Authority Checker
                                            • Local Citation Checker
                                            • MozBar Extension
                                            • MozCast
                                            Resources
                                            • Blog
                                            • SEO Learning Center
                                            • Help Hub
                                            • Beginner's Guide to SEO
                                            • How-to Guides
                                            • Moz Academy
                                            • API Docs
                                            About Moz
                                            • About
                                            • Team
                                            • Careers
                                            • Contact
                                            Why Moz
                                            • Case Studies
                                            • Testimonials
                                            Get Involved
                                            • Become an Affiliate
                                            • MozCon
                                            • Webinars
                                            • Practical Marketer Series
                                            • MozPod
                                            Connect with us

                                            Contact the Help team

                                            Join our newsletter
                                            Moz logo
                                            © 2021 - 2026 SEOMoz, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. All rights reserved. Moz is a registered trademark of SEOMoz, Inc.
                                            • Accessibility
                                            • Terms of Use
                                            • Privacy