Content Organization/ Prioritization
-
This post is deleted! -
I think one issue you are having is targeting the same keywords on multiple pages. I would recommend doing some extensive keyword research with Moz and mapping all your keywords to their appropriate urls or landing pages. Build out a keyword map and write content accordingly.
One quick solution for your "just-listed" pages you could canonicalize them to the neighborhood page or target different keywords on that page.
Hope that helps some.