Https address has different result that http in Page Optimization Score toll in Moz PRO

[TrueluxGroup]

The following url
https://www.whichledlight.com/t/gu10-led-bulbs has (100 score for keyword 'GU10 LED')
has different on page opmisation score results to
http://www.whichledlight.com/t/gu10-led-bulbs (73 score for keyword 'GU10 LED')

Anyone know if we've set something up wrong?
Also, is this even something to worry about, does google treat them differently?

We're using the Page Optimisation Tool in Moz Pro

** UPDATE **

It's worth mentioning we are using emberjs, so the website is a single page application.
We use prerender to render the pages for google.

[Chris_Hickman]

Hello there, Yes, Google treats these as two unique addresses. It's very important when switching to a SSL that you re-direct non-secured pages to their secured version. You'll want to implement 301 permanent redirects and rel=canonical tags or you will continue to have duplicate content concerns.

[TrueluxGroup]

Are our pages currently doing that?

Sorry, development team isn't online at the minute.

Thanks for replying as well

[DavidLee]

Hello!

The scores will not be accurate for either version as the pages are in javascript which our tool cannot crawl as it only can read standard HTML content.

[TrueluxGroup]

Hi David,

We do have prerender (https://prerender.io/) serving the pages... wouldn't that mean they'll be being crawled correctly?

[TrueluxGroup]

Hi David...
Just checking you saw the other reply we sent?

Cheers

[DavidLee]

So it doesn't appear to be a javascript issue. I looked at your campaign and the page getting 73 is actually for http://whichledlight.com/t/gu10-led-bulbs without the www which re-directs to the home page.

The on-page tool for that URL is grading https://www.whichledlight.com/

:)

[TrueluxGroup]

Would this affect how google crawls us you think?