Eric,
I don't think creating two pages for essentially going after the same keywords is a sound strategy. If you created two pages you'll just be cannibalizing your rankings and not to mention potential duplicate content issues that would arise. Since there is not a lot of competition for either of phrases, i think you can rank for both keywords with one page.
What i would do is take the stronger page from the two listed above and optimize that page for both of the phrases. Add relevant content with both phrase, making sure to update the title tags, meta tags and H-tags to include your #1 targeted keyword phrase. After this, you will need to build internal links from other pages to this page with the targeted keyword phrase.
I hope this can help.
- Samir