Thanks for the advice - it really helped! I guess I should reframe the question now that I have a better understanding of what goals I actually should be pursuing.
I do have a more specific question: There are a few older links that show up as results on the front page when I google the company name. Our site was recently redesigned and there are newer sites with updated, but similar content. If I place a 301 redirect on the older pages, will the newer site take the place of the old address in the SERP? Will I have to edit the older pages in the sitemap? Will I have to throw a rel=canonical on the newer page?
Thanks again for all the help, guys!