Welcome to the Q&A Forum

Cool - yeah that was a good question.  Again I think how you proceed depends on exactly what your strategy is.   And if you really don't have a ton of content to justify the infinite scroll then I can see that advantages of getting it all one page - but if it is cumbersome for the user then that is where infinite scroll is so helpful.

Ok so long time in getting back to this, but here's what the client was actually referring to and found a good post on optimization around the new approach. SEO Tips for Infinite Scrolling | Adam Sherk - excellent read! Wasn't sure exactly what this programmer/client was referring to, but this was it! Thanks all for the help!

You are so welcome, and believe me, I understand how hard it can be to convince a client to either not do something or do something differently, because from their perspective all they see is whether the page works or doesn't work. It cost us $1,000 to get a developer to fix our meta refresh and I would never have been able to convince the company to spend the money if SEOMoz had provided some support and validation to the plan. Good luck!