Complex duplicate content question

[mreeves]

We run a network of three local web sites covering three places in close proximity. Each sitehas a lot of unique content (mainly news) but there is a business directory that is shared across all three sites. My plan is that the search engines only index the business in the directory that are actually located in the place the each site is focused on. i.e. Listing pages for business in Alderley Edge are only indexed on alderleyedge.com and businesses in Prestbury only get indexed on prestbury.com - but all business have a listing page on each site.

What would be the most effective way to do this? I have been using rel canonical but Google does not always seem to honour this.

Will using meta noindex tags where appropriate be the way to go? or would be changing the urls structure to have the place name in and using robots.txt be a better option.

As an aside my current url structure is along the lines of:

http://dev.alderleyedge.com/directory/listing/138/the-grill-on-the-edge

Would changing this have any SEO benefit?

Thanks

Martin

[Tom-Anthony]

I'd suggest that rel canonical is the perfect way to handle this. What seems to be the problem with this approach that makes you want to chance it?

[mreeves]

I thought the same but a couple of weeks ago when I was reviewing the impact of implementing rel canonical (which was done several months earlier) I was find quite a number of situations whether Google was not taking notice of the rel canonical guidance and was using the wrong site within its search results (having difficulty finding a specific example at the moment though). The conclusion I came to was Google simply views rel canonical as a suggestion rather than a rule.

[JonathanLeplang]

Maybe this article on the Matt Cutts blog can help you : http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/rel-canonical-html-head/

[sferrino]

I went through both sites and noticed that you don't have canonicals on any of your pages. Also don't see any XML sitemaps.

If you can only show the businesses that are in that particular area, and remove the ones that are not I would  probably go for that, unless you are doing Local Search as well.

I would be curious to see the example of canonical issue you mentioned.

Are these Joomla sites? I'm just asking because there are no description tags on anything except the home page.