Value of Linkworthy Resource Pages

[SparkplugDigital]

Suppose you create a great resource that links to the top 50 blogs in your industry. The blogs in your industry love it and many of them link to that page.

How valuable are those inbound links? I would think some factors hurting the value of these links are that they are not pointing to an important page on your site like the home page or main category page, and the 50 links on the page dilutes the linkjuice that is passed back to the homepage. Or is the main value in making the domain's link equity stronger?

[EGOL]

Most of them will be nofollowed.

But those that are not will count towards your domain authority.

The real value is determined by how powerful your site is at present.  If you have a new site then these links would be a fantastic boost.  But if your site is mature and established with 100,000 links then the 5 good ones that you get from this exercise will not add notice to your rankings.

Honestly... I would rather have a provocative piece of content that would attract those same five links, hundreds more, gets tweeted and liked,  and competes in the SERPs for a kickass KW.

[AlanBleiweiss]

You're partially correct.  To get actual value, the page should not simply be a page with links.  It should be a full blown "top fifty" type article, with extensive commentary on the reason why each is on the list.

By going this route, the page itself becomes more valuable from an on-site content perspective; the outbound links have more value (each link is integrated within descriptive paragraph based content targeting that business' specific offerings (thus keyword and brand relevant); and any inbound links in turn equate to higher value inbound links to an inner page on your site.  Links to inner pages are vital in today's SEO best practices when done properly.

While not as valuable as a full blown content piece with only a few outbound links, it's still more than what is essentially a doorway page.

[AlanMosley]

You may be better off sending that link juice to your own pages rather then to the blogs, seeing that they may not link back to you with a do-follow link.

what would make someone link to your page, the fact that you have a link to them? or that you speak highly of them. why not just do article on the blogs with no links, if you speak highly of them they will more then likly link to you.
PS this would create 1 way links rather than 2 way