Hit By Penguin...Wait for recovery or do i change domains?

[QudosAnimations]

I have been working hard to recover from Penguin..and keep cleaning my backlink structure...and the site start getting value and now with Penguin update 5 or 2.1 the website again lost value.. Our website have huge no of backlinks and most of the website owners are not responding.

Shall I wait for recovery or can i change the domain with same content and dead the olde one?

[GPainter]

Hiya,

if they (webmasters) don't respond use the disavow keep track for the sake of proving you tried to get hold of them. It's a hell of a lot more work to start from scratch then to remove some bad links. I wouldn't recommend sitting on your hands as the problem wont go away by its self.

Unfortunately penguin is doing its job and making sure you don't have a rubbish back link profile so I recommend removing the bad links and getting some good content on your site to help get some great links.

Good luck.

[Dr-Pete]

I don't know that anyone can answer that question without deep knowledge of the site. I agree with Chris that starting from scratch is a big move. Have you attempted to disavow the bad links? It's your next reasonable step. Unfortunately, we're unclear on the Penguin data update cycle, so seeing a positive result from this could take weeks (or longer).

If (1) nothing seems to be working, or (2) you have no good links left after the clean-up, or (3) you simply can't risk waiting any longer - from a business standpoint - then, starting over may be your only option. Keep in mind that you don't want to 301-redirect the old site (you could transfer the penalty), so you really will be starting from scratch. You'll also be taking on a new domain name, which could have many implications (positive and negative). The best you can do at that point is try to re-point some of your old, good links to the new site and at least reclaim some of that link equity.

It's a huge decision, and you need to look at all the ramifications. I would also dig deep and be absolutely sure that Penguin is the only thing that's hitting you. If you do this, and it turns out there's something about the site/content itself harming you, you're going to have made a huge change only to end up in the same situation.

[Coraltoes77]

Hi Manroop,

You posted this a while ago and I wondered what you decided to do in the end and what the outcome was.  I'm interested as I, too, have been hit by Penguin. I've disvowed/removed links, but have not had any further joy - although I need to wait until the next Penguin update before deciding on next steps.  Probably changing the domain is the next step.