Over Optimisation Penalty

[seo-wanna-bs]

Wow I posted a post, along with my URL and it disappeared? Anyway thanks for the info, I didn't know only Pro members can see the replies.

[redacted by staff] is the URL.

Keyword "Nokia N8 Themes". After 12 months with top spots, it's gone.

As you'll see, I've updated the

tag already to differ slightly from the title.

Looking at competitors sites, you'll see they are all similar in format, although most have a differing

to <title></p> <p>Thanks :)</p></title>

[RyanKent]

Regarding the disappearing post, please send an e-mail to help@seomoz.org and share the details including your browser name and version. A few of us have been working to have this issue resolved as it is quite frustrating.

For your issue, when was the last time you noticed your site ranked for "nokia n8 themes" and what was it's position?

While your site is not on page 1 for the phrase, another page from your site is ranked #17 in Google.com for the phrase "nokia n8 themes": [redacted by staff] news/top-10-nokia-n8-themes

This result leads me to believe there is a cannibalization issue on your site. I took a look and you do an excellent job of using anchor text on the ranked page for the term "nokia n8 themes" linking it back to the proper page.

Your page title is "Free Nokia N8 Themes" and header is "Free Themes for your Nokia N8 Phone". Both support the target phrase. Adding a bit of variation between the two is a nice way to include word variations. I would suggest researching the most popular keywords associated with the phrase. Based on a quick AdWords review, I would suggest "Free Nokia N8 Phone Themes" as a slightly better header.

As a note, I tried a site search for "nokia n8 themes" and it returned no results. I was trying to determine if there was an signs of cannibalization elsewhere on your site.

Your backlink profiles for each page look good although there is a page titled "nokia n8 themes" which offers a link to the Top 10 page.

The biggest issue I see is despite your title tag and header, the target phrase is not even used a single time in content on the page. That is a major concern. My suggestion is to add the phrase at least once on the page, preferably as early as possible on the page. That change plus the other changes you have made should lead to the page ranking ahead of, or instead of, the other page from your site.

[seo-wanna-bs]

Hey Ryan. Some good points.

I believe the page was number 1. But I wasn't monitoring it much for a while, until I noticed it had disappeared.

I actually removed the instance of "nokia n8 themes" on the page, because of the concern of too many instances on the page. But you're right, it should likely appear once.

Once the rank disappeared. The top 10 Nokia N8 Themes page, then started to rank on page 2.

The search on the site, only searches keywords, rather than brands or models etc.

Just did a quick google site search for the term and it's just started to show the correct page, first. But searching the term alone, it's still a gonna. http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=nokia+n8+themes+site:[redacted by staff] &ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8

Then search Nokia n8 Themes [redacted] and the correct page ranks. http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=nokia+n8+themes+site:[redacted by staff]&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8#sclient=psy-ab&hl=en&safe=off&client=safari&rls=en&source=hp&q=nokia+n8+themes+tehkseven&pbx=1&oq=nokia+n8+themes+[redacted]&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=e&gs_upl=330687l331806l0l331849l9l3l0l0l0l0l178l321l0.2l2l0&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.,cf.osb&fp=5b3846bb372396b3&biw=1210&bih=561

So it appears to effect only the direct match "nokia n8 themes". Which is interesting.

Thanks for the responses. I am actually half expecting the page to come back, now that I've removed some of the instances of the KW and diluted the instances of the anchors etc.

[KeriMorgret]

A correction to that Ryan. After two weeks, non-members can see the answers, but cannot reply. Only pro members and those with a certain threshold of mozpoints can answer after the two weeks. (I believe it is still two weeks, that's what it was initially at least).

[seo-wanna-bs]

can Google see the responses too?

Can somebody please do me a fav and remove the url, pls

[RyanKent]

At the top of each reply you make it shows your name. To the right you should see "EDIT" as an option. You can edit your own replies.

Google crawlers cannot access anything beyond your original question for two weeks.

Although....Matt Cutts is registered on SEOmoz

[KeriMorgret]

Just went through and redacted the URL and site name.

I'm not involved with the technical setup of this forum, but as a user not logged in, right now one can only see the question.

[seo-wanna-bs]

Thanks a lot guys still new to the whole SEOMoz Q&A!

[KeriMorgret]

Hi Paul,

I'm going through and seeing if questions are ready to be closed out. It's a little hard to tell in this case. Is your question answered, or should I leave it open?

[seo-wanna-bs]

Sorry missed this, it's ok to close now. Thanks a lot.