Welcome to the Q&A Forum

This could be because of your internal linking or external for that matter. if links are passing green car relevance and PR to one page more than the other this could be the result.

Thanks for your reply. So I finally decided to do this. Now I get 404 errors, so I changed it back in WP. I really want 301 Redirect, some how every plugin I installed cant Automatically detect this. Someone knows if this is even possible?