Welcome to the Q&A Forum

You have a huge amount of high DA links, specifically from boardingarea, hyatt blogs and appsumo.  You need to build a better link profile, not focus so much on 3 sites with high DA, and get links more naturally as often as possible.  Almost every link on your OSE is a "controlled" link - blog comments, profiles, appsumo pages, etc. These links are bad by themselves - they're actually good.  But because they're such a high percentage of what you have as a whole, it can look to Google like you're not really all that popular except to 3 sites. You have 1850 links on OSE from 46 domains - about 35 links per domain, a LOT.  Also, nearly 100% of your anchor text is branded.  That tells me you're controlling it. If I can see you're controlling the anchor text, Google can see it.  Again, diversity is best. 202 of your 1850 links are nofollow, 1650 are dofollow.  As before, a high ratio of nofollow signals spam or controlled link building.  Natural nofollow profiles have 5-10% nofollow ratios, yours is 16% which is a touch high. So I would start with your actual link profile.  It's not likely AIOSEO unless you're doubling up on titles and meta, you should be ok. Also, when you pin things, don't use the non-www version of your site.  Several of your pins have "http://noobtraveler.com" instead of www-noobtraveler.com  I would be as consistent as possible on that particular issue.