Welcome to the Q&A Forum

Hi Morgan. The example that you just posted is working fine, i.e. when you try to go to http://www.morganlindsayphotography.com/author/pnkspikchik/ you're redirected to http://www.morganlindsayphotography.com/ and now when you try to go to those old Wedding 404 pages it goes your current wedding package page.  Seems to all be in order. Cheers!

I don't know if you're looking at the right thing... Your site is listing in Google if you check with a site:morganlindsayphotography.com search, so that's current. Plus DNS tools show that your site is pointing to the correct nameservers: https://www.whatsmydns.net/#NS/morganlindsayphotography.com. Further, there aren't any pages listed that are your old 'html' style: https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=site%3Amorganlindsayphotography.com+inurl%3Ahtml. And I'm seeing pages that have been crawled as recently as February: site search with "past month" selected from search tools. If you're in Google Webmaster Tools and go to Google Index >> Index Status, you'll see a running timeline of how many pages Google has in their index up to recent dates. Starting a new domain and rebuilding your site would be a bad idea as it would only delay OSE further.