Welcome to the Q&A Forum

Hi Alex http://domain.com http://www.domain.com https://domain.com https://www.domain.com Are all 4 diferent pages, also may happen to be the home page of a web site. So OSE might get different information for each of them. I assume that you have your www redirected to the non-www version. In that case, there's a high chance that there are few or none links pointing to that page (www) and it's logical for OSE to score it different. Have I made myself clear? I tried  making it general Best Luck. GR.

I agree with this approach, but I also would be trying to dig into _why _they think they want a second site instead of just coming back with a recommendation. What do they think that will accomplish for them? Sometimes clients will ask you to do something that they think will solve a problem when really they should be asking you how to solve the problem, and the situation as he's described it totally feels like one of those times to me.