Welcome to the Q&A Forum

You are very welcome Boris.

Thanks for the advice John. This is very sensitive contact info due to the nature of our niche.  I do agree that a more simplified lead form on all pages with the extended info on a secure page would be best, but that decision is beyond my control. Besides, if we were to make that change now, wouldn't it just delay the recovery since all urls would change again? So it seems like we're at a point that we should be trying to make things work as is.  It is definitely not the ideal setup, but I think we should still be able to recover rankings with this setup.