How many pages is too many to add to a site at one time?

[RobertFisher]

I think the issue is what is the site about and knowing how the content helps. Not just putting quality content up in a vacuum. So, if the site is about custom writing, and there are 4000 pages of examples, I don't think adding an additional 1000 today will help in any appreciable way. If all the content is dissimilar and each page focuses on some different writing item: sports-football, baseball, basketball, etc. and medicine, etc. and you have no content showing that, I would put it all up as well.

I believe if the content is similar to what is on the site, adding it over time (not five years, but one) could have an interesting impact. Not sure if there is a measure currently.

So, issuing the same type challenge, I challenge anyone to prove putting up 1000 pages of content overnight, with no further description of it, will increase site performance appreciably.

Is an interesting question though.

[EGOL]

If all the content is dissimilar and each page focuses on some different writing item: sports-football, baseball, basketball, etc. and medicine, etc. and you have no content showing that, I would put it all up as well.

yes, I agree completely... this is the best situation possible.

I challenge anyone to prove putting up 1000 pages of content overnight, with no further description of it, will increase site performance appreciably.

When I put up new content it starts making money the next day.  It makes money from pulling visitors from search, makes money from visitors from other destination, and makes money from people who landed on my site from other pages.  That is guaranteed money.   Holding the content back because dripping it out over time might produce a freshness boost is a gamble.

[AdamThompson]

I knew there was a Matt Cutts video on this...just couldn't find it!!!

[RyanKent]

My head is swimming with Matt Cutts videos which is not healthy. If someone asks "is it better to have keywords in the path or page name" my instant thoughts are "Alex Black"..."Green polo shirt"...not bald.

If you don't get the joke, don't worry. You are probably better off for it!

[RobertFisher]

From the point of view in the second paragraph, I agree as well. If it was all new content that could drive new customers or drive current customers to buy additionally, I would put it all up as well.

Certainly when it comes to a small component of the algorithm versus money today...show me the money.

Thx

[RobertFisher]

It was funny, Ryan. I agree Matt Cutts videos would be the last thing you need swimming in your head...

[DougRoberts]

How will visitors to your site react to such an avalanche of content. My worry would be that if you publish too much the individual articles can get lost and don't get the eye-balls they deserve.

If you list new content on the home and/or section pages - how much can they promote?

Another thought I have is if you're publishing 1000's of articles - are you revising/pruning old articles too?

[EGOL]

How will visitors to your site react to such an avalanche of content.

Visitors will not see the avalanche....  Instead they will see a fantastic library of content that is wonderfully organized.

My worry would be that if you publish too much the individual articles can get lost and don't get the eye-balls they deserve.

As for "giving it the eyeballs it deserves"... you can promote it slowly... but it will immediately start pulling traffic from the organic SERPs.

Another thoughtI have is if you're publishing 1000's of articles - are you revising/pruning old articles too?

Sure, we do that all of the time... and publishing new ones tomorrow.

[DougRoberts]

Obviously much depends on the architecture of the site.

Another problem with posting lots of content is creating relevant cross-linking in the content. Unless of course you're relying on tags/related article type widgets to handle this for you and not worry about inline links.

I'm just jealous - my problem is normally struggling to get any content at all!

[EGOL]

Yes, I am jealous too.  I normally spend several days on a single page of content - so seeing someone with hundreds of pages makes me green with envy.

[ArlenRitchie]

Here's an updated video (April 2011) from Matt Cutts that addresses adding a lot of pages all at once: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=XpJacspWz4Y#t=130s