Outsourcing development to external agencies

[StalkerB]

Hmm, agree with Kris that it may be better to redevelop the site, but also agree that it would be worth speaking to an agency about specifics (and the iFrame thing is a weird/bad choice).

If you're an international charity and your subdomains are hosted in individual countries targeting those countries I'd be reluctant to state that you should definitely move them without looking at them individually. If the subdomains are simply because you gave control to the developers to build each site, then it would probably make sense to standardise them.

Also, while microsites aren't always a great idea if some of the subdomains targeted a specific project your charity was undertaking I may also consider the odd exact match domain instead of moving it into a subdirectory, but again, would need to know more so please do get in touch with a few agencies about helping you

Also be very careful with your redirects and map them properly. If you are bringing them all in line with each other and putting them on the one CMS then there's a strong chance your URL structure will change and may even produce duplicates.

And finally, taking this on will probably be quite a large project, so plan accordingly. Site structure, internal linking and updating on page factors can all have huge benefits if done properly.

[Getz.pro]

If these charitable websites are in fact different entities, then sub-domains are good, but I would have different URLs. If you place all these domains after your TLD (top level domain) and they are different, with different physical addresses, this could also send some weird information to SEs and to users.

www.FoodRescue.parentcharity.org

www.YouthOutreach.parentcharity.org

With Food Rescue and Youth Outreach being different organizations I would give them different TLDs.

www.FoodRescue.org

www.YouthOutreach.org

Then be sure to cross link when it is natural to do so.

If they are the same organization, just different outreaches within the org, then I would subfolder each of them.

www.parentcharity.com/food-rescue/

www.parentcharity.com/youth-outreach/

Hope that helps

[tgraham]

Hi Kris, a complete site restructure is on the cards and, while your offer is very kind, this rebuild could easily take up a year of all your developers' time (over 100k pages) and a monster CMS system, think just a little smaller size than the BBC. The nub of the question is can we use external providers of web functionality while still building link equity for our main sites?

[tgraham]

Hi Richard, thank you very much for taking the time to respond but the question isn't about the issues or benefits of subdomains - we already have them and we're looking to consolidate into one domain with subfolders, we know they are not helping.  The question is can we use external providers of web functionality while still building link equity for our main sites or do we have to build and host internally at much greater expense and limited functionality to get credit with the search engine giants even thought we're providing a better user experience?

[Getz.pro]

Please provide URLs. I don't think you clarified what you want. : )

[tgraham]

Hi Barry, thanks for your response - the subdomains are not targeting specific countries and we're aware that they should be brought in from the cold into one subfolder of our main domain. However we're unsure of the best way to do that considering they utilise different technologies to work.

[Getz.pro]

First, sub domains don't HURT you and are recommended if the content is vastly different as I pointed out.

Lets qualify some terms:

external providers = paid developers?

web functionality = what are these functionalities?

Having a developer build your site has not intrinsic negative effect on SEO nor does adding functionality. iFrames are not recommended and if you are getting your functionality through them, that could be an issue.

Define more of what you are doing.

[tgraham]

No problem, for obvious reasons I have to stay anonymous but essentially we have:

www.parentcharity.com
community.parentcharity.com
sales.parentcharity.com

we want to put all of these into:

www.parentcharity.com/community
www.parentcharity.com/sales

but the subdomains community. and sales. are currently hosted externally and in a different programming language

Also the business now requires an events platform but we haven't the resources to build it internally so can it be created externally and integrated and is it even worth doing it?

Thanks.

[tgraham]

Yes - External providers = paid developers and web functionalities defined in urls below (events, communities). We understand that iFrame is a bad solution but it was suggested by an external developer who suggested that they were competant at SEO!  

[StalkerB]

Well, to see if I can clarify your position:

You have multiple subdomains each using a different CMS/system to run and you want to bring them all under one CMS/system during a site restructure.

You could, most likely, run each of the systems in their own folder (e.g. /blog/ is powered by Wordpress, /shop/ is powered by Joomla) but I think this is a case of better to do something well if you're going to do it at all and bring it under one main CMS.

I recently had to do this from a bespoke CMS to an open source one and, as there was no real way for them to talk to one another, it was unfortunately a copy and paste job. I only had about 2000 pages though, so would seem less likely you can manually do it with 100,000

If you can export your content in say XML or a database and then parse it into a format that your main CMS would recognise that may be one way of doing it.

Now looking at your response below you've no coder/programmers as such working for you, so what I've suggested may be a bit beyond what you can achieve without hiring one.

Just to be clear though, you cannot have different parts of a site hosted on different servers, so parentcharity.com/sales and parentcharity.com/community MUST be hosted on the same server.

The language that powers each of these sections CAN be different, but you'll most likely have to speak to your current providers and ask if they can move it to the same server. If it's a bespoke solution they may not be able or willing to move it to a server they don't control.

Let me know what I'm missing

[Getz.pro]

Oh, so community and sales are hosted outside of parentcharity? That's why I was not grabbing what you were saying. That's a bit weird and I understand the conundrum.

First, bringing these pages under the same hosting account should not be an issue as this is simply a copy and paste of folders. Unless the functionality is strictly limited to the hosting company.

If the functionality is proprietary and can't be hosted with the partentcharity, I would leave things as they are until you can afford to re-build the site and just cross link as needed.

[Getz.pro]

Ok, having external developers does not intrinsically negatively impact SEO.

Is the functionality proprietary? If not, why not copy the code from all external hosting accounts to your main hosting account?

[StalkerB]

First, bringing these pages under the same hosting account should not be an issue as this is simply a copy and paste of folders. Unless the functionality is strictly limited to the hosting company.

If the functionality is proprietary and can't be hosted with the partentcharity, I would leave things as they are until you can afford to re-build the site and just cross link as needed.

Yeah, this was the tl;dr for mine I should have put in Sums it up perfectly.

[tgraham]

Yep - you've both got it!

This was the question I needed answering:

Just to be clear though, you cannot have different parts of a site hosted on different servers, so parentcharity.com/sales andparentcharity.com/community MUST be hosted on the same siteserver.

and this is the main problem as the function is proprietary:

_If the functionality is proprietary and can't be hosted with the partentcharity, I would leave things as they are until you can afford to re-build the site and just cross link as needed. _

So we're in a quandry, we can't afford / haven't got the internal developer time to build a bespoke community site and the external functionality is proprietry so we can't bring it in-house and are therefore getting little search value from our subdomained community.

[Getz.pro]

I can't see it drastically hurting you as long as you keep them as subdomains.

iFrames will work if moving to subfolders as long as the page that contains the iFrame has other content and the iFrame resides within the page. If not, the iFrame page (external) won't bring any juice to your page/site.

Still, I would keep as subdomains and cross link when naturally applicable.

Then talk to Kris about getting a new site redone : ) I am sure there are developers in your area that would volunteer as you would provide them with volunteer hours they can write off at the end of the year. And someone local should be empathetic to your cause and you can always bribe with a backlink to their site

[tgraham]

Thanks so much for all of the great information. This really helps in clarifying my understanding of separate sites, subdomains and hosting. Now just need to work out how to pursuade the business to start building a new community platform internally.

[tgraham]

By the way anyone coming to this post might not understand  tl;dr literally means, "Too long; didn't read". I had to look it up!

[Getz.pro]

LOL and I thought it was a typo

[Getz.pro]

You are welcome!

[StalkerB]

So we are asking them to integrate their sites into ours for an extra fee but what we are trying to find out is whether or not this is worth it in terms of search equity for our site if we only lose visitors once they have arrived at our site and are then directed off...?

So are you saying (for example) you want to use Flickr for image hosting, Google Calendar for events planning, Proboards for a forum, Cafepress for a store, that kind of thing? And are worried linking to all this offsite content means you're losing the value having the content on your proper domain would provide?