Is widget linkbaiting a bad idea now that webmasters are getting warnings of unnatural links?

[MarieHaynes]

I was reading this article about how many websites are being deindexed because of an unnatural linking profile and it got me thinking about some widgets that I have created.  In the example given, a site was totally deindexed and the author believes the reason was because of multiple footer links from themes that they created.

I have one site that has a very popular widget that I offer to others to embed into their site.  The embed code contains a line that says, "Tool provided by Site Name".

Now, it just so happens that my site name contains my main keyword.  So, if I have hundreds of websites using this tool and linking back to me using the same anchor text, could Google see this as unnatural and possibly deindex me?

I have a few thoughts on what I should do but would love to hear your thoughts:

1. I could use a php script to provide one of several different anchor text options when giving my embed code.

2. I could change the embed code so that the anchor text is simply my domain name, ie www.mywebsitename.com rather than "my website name".

Thoughts?

[EGOL]

I know that people have gotten into trouble with Google when the widget contained links that were not visible to visitors of the websites that displays the widget.

For the attribution link, I would use my domain as anchor.  That is how natural links are usually given.  It is also much more powerful for your brand.

(Just personal opinion... I think that those link warnings are going out mainly to people who are involved in an organized link network or who are heavily spamming blogs and forums.  I don't think think that a widget will cause problems.)

[danbocain]

This is exactly how I handle similar things. Any badges or widgets should either be branded with just your domain URL, or brand name. Looks natural, also looks better for the end-user (the people visiting the website that the badge/widget is in)

[ChrisDyson]

I wouldn't worry too much if you are using your brand name or domain name then you are building natural links.

Personally, if you have different types of widgets then vary the anchor text / URL in the embed code for each.